My Intentionally Boring Podcast Turned into a Media Empire

The Side Hustle Show is designed to get you motivated and excited. This episode is the opposite — and that’s the whole point. Nothing Much Happens is intentionally boring bedtime content for grown-ups, and it’s been downloaded hundreds of millions of times.

Falling asleep is one of the most universal pain points out there, and Kathryn Nicolai found a way to solve it. Before she was a content creator, Kathryn ran a yoga studio for more than two decades.

She never planned to build a media company. She just wanted to help people sleep the way she’d been doing for herself her whole life.

Six years and 400 episodes later, she now has spawned two books, landed in 35 countries, and grown into a full media company. And she still writes every word herself.

Tune in to Episode 745 of the Side Hustle Show to learn:

how a free podcast can generate multiple income streams
why a premium membership with near-zero churn is the most reliable revenue floor
the storytelling craft behind a sleep show that works and why AI can’t replicate it

Table of Contents show

Download the Podcast Starter Kit

Get the free Podcast Starter Kit

The Side Hustle Nation guide to podcasting equipment and software, producing a quality show, growing your audience, and making money.

From Yoga Studio to Sleep Podcast

Kathryn was a full-time yoga teacher and studio owner. Every day she talked to people about their health, and sleep came up constantly. She thought she had it figured out — she’d been lulling herself to sleep with stories her whole life. The question was how to get that out of her brain and into theirs.

A traditional book deal felt out of reach without publishing connections, and she didn’t want to self-publish. Then, in the middle of the night, she had an epiphany. She bought a mic right then and launched about six weeks later.

The show’s format — a calming introduction followed by a slow, sensory-rich bedtime story set in “the Village of Nothing Much” — has stayed exactly the same from that first episode.

Growing Without Spending a Dollar on Marketing

Kathryn didn’t advertise. She told people at her yoga studio and mentioned the show on Facebook, and that was about it. The show grew because sleep is a pain point people talk about. If something helps you sleep, you tell your friends.

Downloads went from 150 a day to 200, then suddenly 1,400, then 3,000. Apple featured the show on New & Noteworthy, which poured fuel on the fire.

Celebrities occasionally mentioned the show and created spikes. At one point, 600 people from Brazil flooded her YouTube comments — out of nowhere.

She didn’t spend a dollar on marketing until about a year before this episode recorded. Within about a year of launching, the show had crossed 10 million downloads.

How 10 Million Downloads Opened the Door to a Book Deal

Kathryn had always wanted a traditional book deal.

Once the show hit 10 million downloads, she reached back out to her podcast network and asked if they knew anyone in publishing.

She got connected to a literary agency, they wrote a proposal together, and her agent told her to stop thinking about it and expect a call in about a month.

Nothing Much Book Cover — From: https://shop.nothingmuchhappens.com/collections/bookstore/products/nothing-much-happens-autographed

The agent called 24 hours later. Publishers from around the world were interested. The Nothing Much Happens book included:

12 original exclusive stories written specifically for the book
Recipes, meditations, and full illustrations
Distribution across 35 countries

It was the moment Kathryn realized this was going to be her career.

How Nothing Much Happens Makes Money

Podcast Advertising — Pre-Roll Only

Kathryn started making money from the show in 2020 through podcast ads. But she had one firm rule: pre-roll only. No mid-rolls, no interruptions once a listener is settling in to sleep. She held that line even when networks pushed back.

She worked with Stitcher and iHeart at different points, but limited inventory made it hard for those larger networks to prioritize her show.

About two years ago she moved to a smaller boutique network that has been a much better fit — advertisers who understand the format see strong results, partly because her listeners are actually paying attention in a way that most podcast listeners aren’t.

Premium Membership

The membership launched around 2021–2022 at $40 a year or $5 a month — Kathryn frames it as a dime a day.

Members get:

Ad-free access to all three of her shows
60+ bonus episodes
Long-form “Much More Happens” compilations running up to 10 hours for uninterrupted overnight listening

The membership runs through Supporting Cast and Apple Podcasts. Kathryn prefers Supporting Cast because members keep listening in whatever app they already use — nothing changes except the experience gets better. Apple was added later for listeners who find it easier to subscribe directly there.

The membership now has 13,000-14,000 subscribers, and 97-98% renew. That kind of retention makes it the most reliable revenue stream in the business — a floor that ad revenue, which fluctuates seasonally, can’t match.

Other Revenue

Beyond ads and membership, Kathryn earns book royalties and sells merch. The show remains free, and the free audience keeps growing, which means she hasn’t seen any cannibalization of ad impressions as the paid membership grows.

The Creative Process Behind 400+ Episodes

Kathryn writes everything herself and has no plans to change that. She keeps a running list in her notes app — usually around 100 ideas long — and adds to it constantly. Twenty years of training herself to notice small, pleasant moments as a yoga teacher means she sees potential stories everywhere.

She writes a month ahead on a strict calendar: all stories for one show in a week, then the other, with her short meditation podcast (First This) slotted into gaps. That’s usually two weeks of writing followed by a few days of editing, then a full recording session. Standard episodes run 30–35 minutes; the 10-hour overnight episodes are compiled from existing favorites.

The storytelling craft is deeply intentional. Every element serves the listener’s nervous system:

Stories start with a calming activity and layer in sensory details (smell, texture, temperature) to keep the listener present
No character names, so listeners can step into the story themselves
Everything is written in the past tense, signaling to anxious brains that the story is already over and everyone is fine
No cliffhangers — ever

Can AI Do This?

Kathryn isn’t worried about AI competition. Her shows are built on a deep understanding of nervous system care and mindfulness, not just a string of pleasant words. Yes, you could set an AI voice loose on Wikipedia.

But as she put it, “you don’t want to be rocked to sleep by a robot — there’s no warmth there.”

She also doesn’t use AI in her own production. When I asked if she uses it to outline sequels or generate ideas, she was direct: “I don’t need it and I don’t think I would like it. I don’t like to share my toys.”

What’s Next for Kathryn?

Kathryn is launching an app that recreates the Village of Nothing Much as a virtual space where listeners can do things a regular podcast app can’t support:

Add nature sounds behind stories
Build custom playlists and tag favorites
Take yoga classes and join live journaling and creative writing sessions
Connect with other listeners in a community built around kindness and calm

The community aspect already exists in the comments sections of her current platforms, where listeners have been known to gift premium memberships to strangers who can’t afford them.

She’s also releasing an audiobook, On the Street Where You Live, on July 28. It features Kathryn alongside eight voice actors from Broadway and film and TV, telling longer stories set over three days in the Village of Nothing Much. It’s available for pre-order now wherever you listen to audiobooks.

On the video side, animator Lealie Pivere — who illustrated both of Kathryn’s books — has been gently animating artwork for YouTube and Spotify.

The videos get gradually dimmer as they play, fading to black by the end. Kathryn sees fully animated sleep content as the next genre she helps build, the way she helped build sleep podcasting six years ago.

Kathryn’s #1 Tip for Side Hustle Nation

“Stop waiting to ready to feel ready.”

Episode Links

Looking for More Side Hustle Help?

Start Your Free $500 Challenge. My free 5-day email course shows you how to add $500 to your bottom line.
Join the free Side Hustle Nation Community. The free Facebook group is the best place to connect with other side hustlers and get your questions answered.
Download The Side Hustle Show. My free podcast shares how to make extra money with actionable weekly episodes.